In Brief
B.A. Umesh, convicted of rape, murder, and robbery for the brutal killing of a woman after sexual assault in 1998, sought review of his death sentence and commutation to life imprisonment. The Supreme Court rejected his plea. Examining his criminal history of seven prior convictions, escape from lawful custody, and commission of another robbery within two days of the murder, the Court found this a 'rarest of rare' case. His age (30 years) and status as an ex-police officer aggravated rather than mitigated the offences. The Court held that aggravating circumstances—the brutal manner of crime, defenseless victim, and evidence of no reformation—far outweighed mitigating factors, sustaining the death penalty.
The lawyer headnote and full judgment text are available to registered users.