दिल्ली उच्च न्यायालय ने यह फैसला सुनाया है कि बिना किसी शुल्क के दिए गए कॉरपोरेट गारंटी (Corporate Guarantee) पर वस्तु एवं सेवा कर (Goods and Services Tax) लागू होगा, लेकिन 1 प्रतिशत के अनिवार्य वार्षिक मूल्यांकन (Valuation) नियम को अनुच्छेद 14 के तहत असंवैधानिक मानते हुए रद्द कर दिया।
NEW DELHI — In a consequential tax ruling affecting India’s largest corporate conglomerates and infrastructure developers, the Delhi High Court has held that corporate guarantees issued by parent or holding companies for loans taken by group entities are subject to Goods and Services Tax (GST), even when provided completely free of charge.
However, offering significant partial relief to businesses, a Division Bench comprising Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar struck down the tax department’s practice of treating 1 percent of the guaranteed loan amount per annum as a compulsory minimum taxable value, holding that such an arbitrary floor violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
The judgment was delivered while disposing of a batch of writ petitions filed by major corporate players, including Sterlite Power Transmission, ReNew, Jindal Stainless, Azure Power, Essar Power, and GAIL.
The Core Dispute: Consideration and Related Parties
The central question before the Court was whether a corporate guarantee extended to a lender on behalf of a subsidiary or group firm constitutes a "supply" under the GST framework when no fee, commission, or monetary consideration is charged.
The petitioners contended that corporate guarantees are routinely furnished by parent companies as shareholder activities to protect their existing investments and facilitate easier credit access for subsidiaries. Since no consideration flows back to the guarantor, the companies argued, the transaction should fall outside the purview of GST.
Rejecting this submission, the Delhi High Court observed that the essence of the service does not depend on whether a fee is collected. Instead, the Court noted that the taxable service lies in the guarantor assuming the financial risk of a related party's default and extending its own creditworthiness to secure the loan.
Crucially, the Bench pointed to the statutory architecture of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017. Under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, transactions and supplies made between related persons in the course or furtherance of business are deemed to be taxable supplies even if made without consideration.
Divergence Between High Courts
The ruling deepens a sharp judicial split among Indian High Courts on the taxation of corporate guarantees.
In reaching its conclusion, the Delhi High Court explicitly differed from the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court, which had previously held in DP Jain & Co. Infrastructure that fee-free guarantees executed between 2020 and 2022 were not taxable. The Delhi Bench observed that the Bombay High Court had relied on the Supreme Court’s precedent in Edelweiss Financial Services—a case adjudicated under the pre-GST service tax regime, where monetary consideration was an essential statutory ingredient to define a taxable service. According to the Delhi High Court, the Bombay Bench had not fully examined the deeming fiction created by Schedule I of the CGST Act for related-party transactions.
Instead, the Delhi High Court aligned itself with the Gujarat High Court’s view in Torrent Power, affirming that the supply of service is complete the moment the guarantor executes the deed and assumes the underlying credit risk.
Relief on Valuation and Annual Levy
While upholding the taxability of fee-free guarantees, the Court curtailed the revenue department's aggressive valuation methodology under Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules.
Rule 28(2), introduced in October 2023, sought to deem the value of corporate guarantee services at 1 percent of the amount guaranteed per annum, or the actual consideration, whichever is higher. The Delhi High Court read down this provision, ruling that mandating a 1 percent annual floor without accounting for actual commercial realities or varying risk profiles is arbitrary and unconstitutional under Article 14.
Furthermore, the Bench clarified two vital timelines and operational principles:
- No Recurring Annual Tax: GST is triggered as a one-time supply when the guarantee is executed. Tax authorities cannot levy GST afresh every year merely because the loan tenure continues and the guarantee remains in force.
- Prospective Application of Rule 28(2): The amended valuation mechanism under Rule 28(2) applies strictly to guarantees executed, renewed, extended, or enhanced on or after October 26, 2023. Guarantees issued between July 1, 2017, and October 25, 2023, must be assessed under the general valuation rules prevailing during that period.
Way Forward
Consequently, the High Court set aside the impugned show-cause notices, assessment orders, and tax demands issued to the petitioning companies to the extent they conflicted with its findings, directing adjudicating authorities to grant fresh hearings and recompute liabilities in accordance with the law.
The broader controversy, however, awaits final resolution at the apex court. Just days prior to the Delhi High Court's verdict, the Supreme Court issued notice on special leave petitions challenging the Gujarat High Court’s ruling in Torrent Power and granted an interim stay on disputed GST recovery demands.
Description: The Delhi High Court has ruled that corporate guarantees extended by parent firms for group company loans attract Goods and Services Tax (GST), even when issued completely free of charge. Disposing of petitions by major corporations including Sterlite Power, ReNew, and GAIL, the Division Bench observed that assuming default risk and extending creditworthiness constitutes a taxable supply between related parties under the CGST Act, diverging from a contrary Bombay High Court verdict. However, the Court granted substantial valuation relief by reading down Rule 28(2), declaring the mandatory 1 percent annual valuation floor arbitrary and unconstitutional under Article 14. Furthermore, the Bench clarified that GST is a one-time levy upon execution rather than an annual recurring tax, directing authorities to reassess disputed demands afresh.