Breaking Supreme Court Rejects ECI Claim on Form 6 Changes in Electoral Roll Revision Hearing
New Delhi · Friday, 20 November 2026
Free Law - free judgments and free headnotes Free Lawby De Jure
Legal News 20 November 2026

Gauhati High Court Rules Social Media Posts Showing ‘Enjoyable Life’ Cannot Disqualify Wife from Maintenance

गौहाटी उच्च न्यायालय ने यह महत्वपूर्ण निर्णय दिया है कि सोशल मीडिया पर पोस्ट की गई तस्वीरें पत्नी की वित्तीय आत्मनिर्भरता का कानूनी प्रमाण नहीं हैं, इसलिए उसे अपने पति से भरण-पोषण (maintenance) प्राप्त करने के अधिकार से वंचित नहीं किया जा सकता।

The Gauhati High Court has delivered an important ruling on matrimonial maintenance, clarifying that photographs and updates posted on social media depicting a wife “enjoying life” cannot, by themselves, establish that she is financially self-sufficient or capable of funding her own lifestyle. Setting aside an order passed by the Family Court at Nalbari, a Division Bench headed by Justice Michael Zothankhuma restored the wife’s claim for financial support and directed the husband to pay ₹2,000 per month as maintenance.

Background of the Matrimonial Dispute

The dispute arose out of a marriage solemnized in March 2023. Within approximately three months of the wedding, matrimonial discord led to the separation of the couple, with the wife leaving the matrimonial home. Following the separation, she instituted proceedings before the Family Court in Nalbari seeking monthly maintenance of ₹15,000 from her husband to meet her living expenses.

During the trial before the Family Court, the husband opposed the claim by relying heavily on the wife’s online presence. He produced material from her social media accounts to argue that she was residing in Guwahati and leading a comfortable, enjoyable lifestyle. Accepting this line of argument, the Family Court dismissed the wife’s maintenance petition. The trial court reasoned that her social media uploads demonstrated she was an able-bodied woman living well in Guwahati and possessed the capacity to earn and sustain herself without financial assistance from her husband.

Aggrieved by the complete rejection of her maintenance plea, the wife approached the Gauhati High Court challenging the legality and propriety of the Family Court’s order.

Arguments and Financial Assessment Before the High Court

Before the High Court, Advocate D. Pathak, appearing for the petitioner-wife, contended that the Family Court had erred in treating curated social media posts as conclusive proof of financial independence. It was submitted that although the wife had previously worked as a saleswoman and sales promoter with Lavaniya Trade & Agencies on a modest monthly remuneration of ₹7,500, she was no longer in employment and lacked independent resources to maintain herself. Conversely, the wife alleged that the husband earned around ₹50,000 per month from his regular employment, a shop, agricultural land, a pig farm, and a commercial goods vehicle.

On the other hand, Advocate S. Paul, representing the respondent-husband, defended the Family Court’s order and argued that the wife had voluntarily withdrawn from the marriage without sufficient cause. He maintained that his disclosed monthly salary was roughly ₹14,000 and that the wife’s employment certificate and online lifestyle proved she required no monetary support.

Examining the documentary record, the High Court found that the wife’s allegations regarding the husband’s ₹50,000 monthly income were not backed by concrete evidence. However, taking note of his admitted salary of around ₹14,000 alongside income from a shop and unexplained loan repayments reflected in his financial records, the Bench conservatively assessed the husband’s monthly income at ₹18,000. Regarding the wife, the Court noted from the certificate issued by Lavaniya Trade & Agencies that she had been earning ₹7,500 per month.

Key Judicial Observations

Overturning the Family Court’s findings, the Gauhati High Court observed that digital snapshots of a person appearing happy or enjoying social outings do not constitute legal proof of steady income or economic self-reliance. The Bench emphasized that an inference of financial capability cannot be drawn merely from social media appearances.

The Court further clarified a settled principle of maintenance jurisprudence: even if a wife earns a modest income—such as ₹7,500 per month—and can sustain herself at a basic level, she is not barred from claiming supplemental maintenance. She remains legally entitled to financial support from her husband so that she may maintain a standard of living reasonably commensurate with what she was accustomed to in the matrimonial home.

Additionally, the Bench rejected the plea of desertion, noting that there was no evidence showing the wife had refused to resume cohabitation, especially as neither spouse had sought divorce nor had the husband filed for restitution of conjugal rights. While determining the quantum, the Court reiterated that the frequently cited benchmark of awarding 25 percent of a husband’s net income is only a broad guideline rather than an inflexible statutory formula, and maintenance must be tailored to the specific facts and financial realities of each case.

Final Order

Allowing the appeal in part, the Gauhati High Court set aside the Nalbari Family Court’s order and directed the husband to pay ₹2,000 per month toward the wife’s maintenance, effective from November 2026, payable on or before the seventh day of every month.

Description:The Gauhati High Court has held that social media photographs showing a wife “enjoying life” cannot, by themselves, establish that she is financially self-sufficient or capable of maintaining her own lifestyle. Setting aside a Nalbari Family Court order that had denied maintenance based on the wife’s online posts in Guwahati, a Division Bench headed by Justice Michael Zothankhuma restored her claim for support.

Assessing the husband’s monthly income at ₹18,000, the Court observed that even though the wife previously earned ₹7,500 per month as a sales promoter, a modest income does not disqualify her from claiming supplemental maintenance to preserve a standard of living comparable to her matrimonial home. Clarifying that the 25 percent maintenance benchmark is merely a guideline, the High Court directed the husband to pay ₹2,000 per month from November 2026.

Have a legal problem? Ask a lawyer - free.
Post your question free of cost and advocates near you can respond. Or use Talk to a Lawyer option to instantly connect with an advocate.
Ask your question free →
Are you a lawyer?
Get listed free on the advocates directory. Search Supreme Court judgments with headnotes. Daily court updates and citizen queries from your city.
Join Free Law →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can social media posts be used to deny a wife maintenance?

The Gauhati High Court ruled that photographs and updates on social media depicting a wife enjoying life cannot by themselves establish financial self-sufficiency or serve as legal proof of steady income.

Does a modest prior income disentitle a wife from claiming maintenance?

No, the High Court clarified that even if a wife earns a modest income, she remains legally entitled to supplemental maintenance from her husband to maintain a standard of living comparable to her matrimonial home.

Is the 25 percent income rule for maintenance mandatory?

The High Court reiterated that the frequently cited benchmark of awarding 25 percent of a husband's net income is merely a broad guideline rather than an inflexible statutory formula.

What maintenance amount was awarded by the Gauhati High Court in this case?

Assessing the husband's monthly income at ₹18,000, the Gauhati High Court set aside the trial court order and directed him to pay ₹2,000 per month as maintenance to the wife.