कर्नाटक उच्च न्यायालय ने असकिन्स बायोफ्यूल्स बनाम भारत संघ मामले में केंद्र सरकार द्वारा एथेनॉल निर्माण के लिए गन्ने के रस और बी-हैवी शीरे के उपयोग पर लगाई गई रोक पर अंतरिम स्थगन (interim stay) देने से इनकार कर दिया, यह कहते हुए कि देश में चीनी की कमी को रोकने के लिए सार्वजनिक हित निजी व्यावसायिक हितों से ऊपर है।
BENGALURU: The High Court of Karnataka has refused to grant interim relief staying the Union Government’s directive prohibiting the diversion of sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for ethanol manufacturing during the 2026–27 Ethanol Supply Year. Observing that private commercial operations cannot take precedence over regulatory measures enacted to prevent a nationwide sugar deficit, the Court declined to interdict the October 22, 2026 notification issued by the Department of Food and Public Distribution.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice CM Poonacha, while hearing a writ petition in Askins Biofuels Pvt Ltd & Anr v. Union of India & Ors, rejected the request to suspend the operation of the Central directive pending final adjudication of its constitutional and statutory validity. The order, passed on November 17, 2026, places public availability of an essential commodity squarely above individual business continuity at the interlocutory stage.
Background of the Dispute
The challenge was initiated jointly by Askins Biofuels Private Limited, a standalone ethanol distillery, and Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, a jaggery manufacturing enterprise proposing to supply sugarcane juice and syrup to the distillery for biofuel production.
On October 22, 2026, the Central Government’s Department of Food and Public Distribution promulgated an order barring sugar mills and distilleries from utilising sugarcane juice, sugar syrup, and B-heavy molasses for ethanol production throughout the 2026–27 ethanol sugar cycle, spanning November 2026 to October 2027. Aggrieved by the abrupt restriction on their feedstock arrangements, the petitioners approached the High Court seeking to quash the directive and requesting an immediate stay so their manufacturing facilities could remain operational.
Submissions Before the Court
Appearing for the petitioners, Advocate Anirudha Ramchandra Nayak contended that the feedstock earmarked for their ethanol production originated solely from the five per cent cultivation area traditionally left to the discretion of sugarcane farmers. Counsel submitted that ninety-five per cent of the allotted sugarcane cultivation area remained dedicated to conventional sugar production, meaning their procurement would not materially disrupt domestic sugar stocks.
The petitioners further emphasised the severe economic fallout of the prohibition, arguing that an immediate enforcement of the October 22 directive would force a total shutdown of their industrial operations. Such a halt, they contended, would inflict irreparable financial injury on the companies and threaten the livelihoods of workers employed at the distillery unit.
Opposing the prayer for interim relief, Additional Solicitor General K Aravind Kamath, representing the Union of India, underscored that the impugned directive was a necessary policy intervention driven by projected domestic sugar scarcity. Relying on cane production estimates for the 2026–27 agricultural cycle, the Additional Solicitor General argued that any diversion of sugarcane juice or syrup toward biofuel manufacturing would directly reduce the volume of sugar reaching consumer markets.
The Union Government also clarified the limited scope of the prohibition, pointing out that the October 22 notification does not bar distilleries from producing ethanol using C-heavy molasses. Defending the legal validity of the action, the Central counsel submitted that the executive possessed clear statutory competence to issue such restrictions under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955—which empowers the government to regulate the production, supply, and distribution of essential commodities—read alongside the Sugar (Control) Order, as amended in 2025. He further noted that the restrictions were purely temporary and remained subject to periodic review based on updated sugarcane harvest assessments.
The Court’s Reasoning and Directions
After evaluating the rival submissions, Justice CM Poonacha held that no case was made out for granting an interim stay against the Central directive. The Bench noted that the October 22 order had been promulgated after factoring in prevailing market conditions and sugarcane yield projections for 2026–27 indicating a potential sugar shortage.
In its order, the Court observed that when regulatory curbs are introduced to manage an essential commodity deficit, the commercial activities of private entities cannot prevail over broader public supply imperatives. Consequently, the Bench declined to interdict the government notification at the preliminary stage.
While denying a stay, the High Court granted liberty to the petitioners to submit a formal representation before the competent authorities seeking any relaxations permissible under existing law. The Court has scheduled the matter for further hearing on January 7, 2027.
Description: The Karnataka High Court has refused to grant interim relief staying the Central Government’s October 22, 2026 order prohibiting the diversion of sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for ethanol production during the 2026–27 Ethanol Supply Year. Hearing a writ petition filed by Askins Biofuels Private Limited and Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, a Single Judge Bench of Justice CM Poonacha observed that private commercial activities cannot take precedence over regulatory measures enacted to prevent a domestic sugar shortage. While the Union Government defended the temporary restriction under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 and clarified that ethanol production from C-heavy molasses remains permitted, the Court denied a stay, granted liberty to seek permissible relaxations, and listed the matter for January 7, 2027.