Breaking Supreme Court Rejects ECI Claim on Form 6 Changes in Electoral Roll Revision Hearing
New Delhi · Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Free Law - free judgments and free headnotes Free Lawby De Jure
Legal News 18 November 2026

Karnataka High Court Directs ASI to Issue Formal Orders for Removal of Encroachments Around Gulbarga Fort

कर्नाटक उच्च न्यायालय (Karnataka High Court) ने भारतीय पुरातत्व सर्वेक्षण (ASI) को निर्देश दिया है कि वह गुलबर्गा किले के आसपास के अवैध अतिक्रमणों (encroachments) को हटाने के लिए नियम 38(2) के तहत औपचारिक आदेश जारी करे ताकि जिला मजिस्ट्रेट कार्रवाई कर सकें।

BENGALURU: In a significant ruling aimed at preserving historical heritage, the Karnataka High Court has directed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to pass formal statutory orders authorizing the District Magistrate to demolish unauthorized encroachments in and around the historic Gulbarga Fort.

A Division Bench comprising Justices Anu Sivaraman and KS Bharath Kumar issued the directive on November 18, 2026, while hearing a long-standing Public Interest Litigation (PIL) concerning the preservation of the protected monument. The Court emphasized that preliminary administrative correspondence is legally insufficient to trigger demolition drives, underscoring the necessity of strict adherence to statutory procedure under heritage conservation laws.

The Statutory Bottleneck

The proceedings stem from a 2018 PIL initiated by architect and heritage activist Sharan Desai (Sharan Desai MS USA v. Superintending Archaeologist & Ors.), seeking urgent judicial intervention to clear illegal structures that have mushroomed both inside the fort premises and within its regulated peripheral zone.

During the hearing, Advocate Safalya S Wagle, representing the Archaeological Survey of India, informed the Bench that the Joint Director-General of the ASI had already initiated administrative steps toward clearing the encroachments. However, the counsel submitted that the central agency had not received a fruitful or actionable response from the Karnataka State authorities to carry out the physical removal on the ground.

Evaluating this submission, the Division Bench pointed directly to the procedural mandate under Rule 38(2) of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Rules, 1959. Under the statutory framework governing centrally protected monuments, the Central Government or the Director-General of the ASI must pass a specific, formal order directing the removal of unauthorized buildings or structures. Once such an order is formally issued and communicated, the District Magistrate is legally empowered and obligated to execute the demolition and recover the costs from the encroachers.

The Court observed that without a formal order passed under Rule 38(2) placed on record, district administration officials lack the requisite statutory authorization to initiate demolition proceedings. Consequently, the Bench directed the ASI to immediately formalize its decision by passing the necessary orders under the 1959 Rules so that the District Magistrate can proceed in accordance with the law.

Background of the Litigation

Gulbarga Fort, located in Kalaburagi district, is a monument of national importance dating back to the 14th century, renowned for its distinct Bahmani architecture and historical significance. Over the decades, rapid urbanization and lax enforcement have led to severe encroachment issues within the monument's precincts.

Pursuant to earlier orders passed by the High Court in this PIL, joint surveys conducted by the ASI and local revenue authorities had identified nearly 300 unauthorized structures situated within the protected and prohibited areas of the fort. Under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958, a 100-metre radius surrounding a protected monument is designated as a "prohibited area" where no new construction is permitted, followed by a further 200-metre "regulated area" requiring prior permission from the National Monuments Authority.

Throughout the course of the litigation, the High Court has closely monitored multiple facets of the restoration process, including:

  • The accurate physical demarcation of the 100-metre prohibited zone around the fort walls.
  • The formulation and execution of a comprehensive rehabilitation scheme by the State Government for eligible families residing in the encroached zones prior to eviction.
  • Coordinated action between the ASI, the Kalaburagi District Administration, and local municipal bodies to prevent fresh unauthorized constructions.

Next Steps

With the High Court clearing the procedural ambiguity, the onus now lies on the Archaeological Survey of India to issue the formal Rule 38(2) directives without further delay. Once the orders are transmitted to the District Magistrate of Kalaburagi, the district administration will be legally bound to execute the removal of the identified illegal structures while ensuring compliance with the Court's earlier directions regarding due process and state-sponsored rehabilitation. The matter remains under the active monitoring of the Division Bench to ensure timely compliance by both central and state authorities.

Description: The Karnataka High Court has directed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to pass formal statutory orders empowering the District Magistrate to demolish unauthorized encroachments in and around the historic Gulbarga Fort. Hearing a long-standing 2018 Public Interest Litigation filed by architect Sharan Desai, a Division Bench of Justices Anu Sivaraman and KS Bharath Kumar noted that preliminary administrative correspondence is legally insufficient to trigger eviction drives. Under Rule 38(2) of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Rules, 1959, a specific formal order from the ASI is mandatory on record before district authorities can execute demolitions. The directive aims to clear nearly 300 identified illegal structures within the monument's protected and prohibited zones while ensuring parallel compliance with state rehabilitation measures.

Have a legal problem? Ask a lawyer - free.
Post your question free of cost and advocates near you can respond. Or use Talk to a Lawyer option to instantly connect with an advocate.
Ask your question free →
Are you a lawyer?
Get listed free on the advocates directory. Search Supreme Court judgments with headnotes. Daily court updates and citizen queries from your city.
Join Free Law →

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Karnataka High Court direct the ASI to pass formal orders?

The High Court observed that preliminary administrative correspondence is legally insufficient for district officials to initiate demolitions. Under Rule 38(2) of the 1959 Rules, a formal statutory order from the ASI is mandatory to empower the District Magistrate to remove unauthorized structures.

Who filed the PIL regarding encroachments at Gulbarga Fort?

The Public Interest Litigation was filed in 2018 by architect and heritage activist Sharan Desai.

What are the prohibited and regulated zones around protected monuments?

Under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958, a 100-metre radius around a protected monument is a prohibited area where no new construction is permitted, followed by a 200-metre regulated area.

How many unauthorized structures were identified around Gulbarga Fort?

Joint surveys conducted by the ASI and local revenue authorities identified nearly 300 unauthorized structures within the protected and prohibited areas of Gulbarga Fort.