In Brief
Commodore Banerjee, an Indian Navy officer, appealed against the Armed Forces Tribunal's dismissal of his challenge to adverse Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs) that he claimed prevented his promotion to Rear Admiral. Though the Supreme Court agreed that adverse remarks in his 2008 ACR were illegally not communicated to him and were properly expunged, it upheld the AFT's decision that this expungement provided sufficient remedy. The Court found no cascading effect on subsequent reports and upheld the Navy's moderation of his numerical grades under its PARB system as legitimate and consistent with his overall profile. The Court affirmed his non-promotion resulted from comparative merit, not the adverse remarks, though it expressed hope for his future promotion consideration.",
The lawyer headnote and full judgment text are available to registered users.