In Brief
Dr. Sadachari Singh Tomar, a scientist at the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), challenged his premature removal from a five-year Research Management Position and reversion to a lower rank. He alleged the action was retaliatory for exposing financial irregularities. The Supreme Court dismissed his appeals, holding that Article 311 does not protect employees of autonomous societies like ICAR. The Court found his tenure appointment contained an "until further orders" clause permitting early termination, and his reversion was based on non-stigmatic performance assessments. Without concrete evidence of mala fides, unsubstantiated allegations of retaliation could not override the administrative decision.
The lawyer headnote and full judgment text are available to registered users.