In Brief
This case involved a joint investigation into the murder of a former Gujarat home minister and an attempted murder of a VHP leader, with the CBI alleging they were part of a larger terrorist conspiracy under POTA. The accused claimed their confessional statements were obtained forcibly and denied involvement in the alleged conspiracy. The trial court convicted some accused, but the High Court acquitted them, finding insufficient evidence of the conspiracy. The CBI appealed, challenging the acquittal as perverse. The Supreme Court dismissed the CBI's appeals, holding that absent gross perversity, acquittals cannot be interfered with. The evidence and statements were insufficient to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and the High Court's acquittal was legally sound."
The lawyer headnote and full judgment text are available to registered users.